A bearded man chewing on a straw unties a swan boat, pats the railing on the dock, then tells us to get in.
We step into a plastic swan paddleboat on the lake in Central Park. Normally, the park only has gondolas or rowboats, but once a year it’s Swan Boat Day.
“No rocking. No swan boat bumper cars, and no making out,” he barks at us.
“Aye-aye, captain,” Oliver says, backing the boat out of the dock, the churning of the paddles beneath the boat like a roller coaster chugging uphill.
I push hard with my yellow flip-flops as we pedal around the lake at top speed—maybe three miles an hour. We cruise past other boaters, enjoying the sun and the water.
“Is this too teenager-y for you, Mr. I’m So Sophisticated?” I ask. “Are you sure it’s not your fun police duty to arrest us?”
“It’s more fun than shopping,” he says as we pedal through a sunny patch of water, past another group of boaters.
I wave to them before turning my narrow-eyed gaze on Oliver. “But you seemed to be having fun shopping. You made me get the dress.”
He eyes me from top to bottom, his green eyes shimmering with a hint of desire. He’s not trying to hide it, and that heats me up, especially when he says, “Well, it looks good on you. I had no choice.”
“No choice? Really?”
“When a woman looks this good, she can’t not wear the thing that makes her look this hot,” he says, his eyes locked on mine.
His words and his gaze make my stomach flip as tingles spread down my chest.
“See? You have your laws, and so do I.” The way he says it, all low and sexy, makes my pulse speed up.
I shouldn’t like this, but I do. God, I do.
I like knowing he’s still affected, still attracted to me, even though we laid down the rules.
We made our choices.
But it feels like the choices are making us.
And try as we might to reroute back to friendship, we keep tipping into the danger zone.
Soon we reach a quiet corner of the lake where it feels like it’s just us. He stops pedaling, and we soak in the sun.
Maybe it’s best to remember those choices. To remind ourselves of why we’re here. So I try. “We made it through last night. We survived.”
“Yes, the cookie batter. Don’t remind me.”
I set a hand on his arm. He tenses, then, after a moment, relaxes. “No, I meant we survived moving past the sex.”
“We did,” he says, pushing out a laugh. “Because I used my patented mind eraser.”
“What’s that?”
He mimes sweeping. “I just get out my broom and sweep the memory into a corner and pretend it never happened.”
“Really?”
“Men are simple, right?”
“I don’t know. I think you’re complicated.”
“Trust me. I’m not. I’m pretty straightforward.”
“So, if I flash my boobs, are boobs all you’re going to think about?” I ask, challenging him.
“I’m sorry. What did you say? I stopped thinking.” He lets his gaze drift playfully down to my chest. “Nice dress.”
“But see, I don’t believe that. You pretend you are shallow, but deep down you think about things like friendship,” I say, as he looks me in the eyes again. “You think about life and death and your parents, and you think about your clients and fighting for them and doing the best you can.”
He looks at me, quiet and studying. “True. Yet sometimes I’m still playing the same loop. Food. Sex. Money.” He takes a beat. “Sex.”
And I might be playing that last one on a loop too. But I’m still trying to make a point, one related to sex, and to all the other things I like about him. “I don’t think that’s all you care about. You care about security. Reliability. Dependability. If you didn’t, we’d be sleeping together again.”
He stares hard at me, his jaw ticking. “Is that why we’re not sleeping together?”
I stare back, feeling the mood shift. My skin is hot, my breath comes fast, and the sun beats down. “Isn’t it?”
“At the moment, I’m honestly not sure.”
Heat roars in my body. “I’m not either. Going back to how we were sounds good in theory . . .”
“But theories can be wrong,” he says, his eyes dark, glimmering with lust.
