“Shit. Fuck,” Brian curses and closes his eyes as he slowly pushes further into me.
The pain isn’t unbearable like I imagined it would be, and I realize Colt was right. I’m so on edge, so wet and horny that this is the perfect time.
I feel a pinch of pain as he meets resistance and pulls back just enough to thrust back in, his lips on mine as he swallows my scream, and a few tears escape.
“You okay?” He looks down at me once he’s fully inside me, and I nod.
“Don’t move for a minute, Brian,” Colten tells him, and then puts his hand between us to play with my clit at a leisurely pace until he has me moaning and wiggling, making Bry hiss above me.
“Fuck, beautiful, I need to move. Can I move?” he asks me, and I nod before throwing my head back as he triggers every nerve inside me when he pulls out and slowly slides back in.
Between him moving in and out of me, slowly picking up the pace and Colt’s hand on my clit, I know I’m not far off.
“I’m close, Bry. Harder,” I beg. I think it’s what I need. “I need you to move the way Colt’s fingers were earlier,” I explain, and he starts thrusting in and out of me harder and faster, sweat beading on his eyebrows.
“You feel inexplicable. I can’t hold on.” He lets out a guttural moan and I can feel him pulsing inside me, knowing he’s cumming.
Colt pinches my clit to send me over the edge with a loud scream, not letting up and dragging my pleasure out until I’m coming down from it all.
“That was…” Brian trails off, lost for words.
“Whoa.” I finish for him, and he collapses on the bed beside me.
The loss of him inside me makes me feel empty, and I sigh and kiss him lovingly before he gets up and heads to the bathroom to, I assume, dispose of the condom.
“You were exquisite, babe. You ready for me?” Colt asks, and I moan.
“Can I die from too much pleasure?” I ask, and he smiles down at me.
“Doubtful, but if you can, what a fucking way to go.” He sits up on his knees and looks down at me with fire in his eyes and I shiver. “Ass on the end of the bed, babe,” he orders me while he stands up.
The look of pure lust and desire has me feeling about ready to combust as I move to do what he says.
He already as the condom on his thick shaft as I stare at it. He’s about the same length as Brian but thicker around. I know he will feel different.
“Don’t look so scared, baby.” He leans over me as he lowers my knees to the sides and kisses me hard. “I have been dreaming about this since the second I saw your sassy ass walk into this school.” He’s kissing me like he wants to punish me, and I think in a way he does.
I also think I’d let him.
Him and I? We feed off one another. We taunt and tease, and hate fiercely. It also means we love fiercely. He brings out the darkness in me just like I bring out the light in him.
When he pulls back to look at me, we’re both panting heavy as he fists his cock and rubs it along my slick lips making me moan.
“Colt please, baby, I need you.” I beg.
“Patience.” He continues to tease me, his dick running up and down my slit as the head occasionally bumps my clit making me hiss. “You’re the first virgin I’ve ever been with, Harleigh. I want you to know that,” he whispers, teasing my clit with his length.
I blink at him, moaning when he rubs against me just the right way. “Thank you. Now, would you stop fucking teasing me and—” He thrusts into me hard, and I lose my words and my breath.
“Fucking hell, you’re so tight, babe,” he groans once he’s seated deep inside me.
The stretch burns a bit, but it also feels like every single nerve is firing on all fucking cylinders as he pulls out and thrusts back in again, making me purr for him.
His hips move in a punishing rhythm as his hands grip me, lifting my ass off the bed. The angle is much different than I felt with Bry. He hit’s something inside me I didn’t know existed, and I scream in frustrated desire.
“What is it, baby?” he growls at me, never letting up his pace.
“I don’t know,” I moan, and lift my hips to meet him thrust for thrust.
I vaguely hear Brian coming back from the bathroom and sitting in the chair. I know he’s watching, but if I look at him, I will come undone and I’m not ready for that yet.
The delicious heat building deep inside my core and up my spine threatens to devour me as Colt moves his one hand around my throat and gently squeezes.
My eyes fly open to look at him, and I can tell he’s about to lose it. I did that to him. To both of them.
“Shit, baby, I’m not going to last long. Cum for me.”
I shake my head as I lift my hips a bit higher to make each of his thrusts hit that intense spot inside me that has me seeing stars.
“There. Please, right there!” I scream, and he growls, squeezing my neck a bit tighter as his hips move harder and faster into me without a rhythm.
“Cum, Harleigh, right the fuck now!” he screams at me, and I shatter into a million pieces. My pussy squeezing so tightly around him that he screams his own release.
“FUUUUUUUUCCCCKKKK!!!”
Both of us pant as he collapses on top of me, still moving his hips at a slower pace to gently bring me back down from the intense orgasm I just felt, before he props up and looks at me.
“Fucking hell, babe.” He’s breathing hard as he talks.
