“We are not doing that, Enzo.”

“Why not?”

I throw up my hands. “You seriously need to ask me that question? You know how I feel about tiny enclosed spaces.”

He knows. He knows everything I’ve been through in the past and how I’ve been locked in a place like that, which I could not escape. Something like that gives you permanent claustrophobia.

This would be a good time for him to drop it, especially if he’s worried about my blood pressure. But for reasons I don’t understand, he doesn’t shut up.

“We could fix it up,” he insists. “Suzette says that⁠—”

“Oh? What does Suzette say? Please tell me everything Suzette thinks.”

He presses his lips together. “You know she is a real estate agent. This is what she does. She is offering her expertise.”

“You know,” I say, “maybe you would make more money if you spent more time working and less time in her yard.”

“I am only in her yard a little bit.”

“You’re always there!” I burst out. “In the middle of the night, no less!”

I hadn’t yet confronted him about finding him in Suzette’s yard at ten at night, and there’s no time like the present, especially when I’m already angry.

He blinks at me. “I do not know what you are talking about.”

“A few weeks ago, I saw you on Suzette’s lawn talking to her while I was putting the kids to bed,” I say. “What were you doing there?”

“I do not remember.” He truly looks like he means it. It’s very tempting to believe him. “She had some question. I think… she wanted a rose bush.”

“At ten at night?”

He shrugs. “Is not so late.”

Maybe not for him, when he’s up until all hours of the night.

“Look,” he says. “This is not about Suzette. It was my idea to convert the room. I thought the extra space would be nice.”

“Extra space?” I burst out. “Enzo, the last place we lived was a two-bedroom apartment in the Bronx. This place still feels like a palace to me.”

“It’s just… it is a lot smaller than Suzette and Jonathan’s house.” He frowns. “You do not want that extra room?”

“I never want to go inside that room again.” I shudder at the thought of it. “And I thought you, of all people, knew me well enough that you wouldn’t even ask. If you want to do something with that room, you can buy some new wallpaper and seal it up so that I never have to look at it again. Okay?”

He opens his mouth as if to say something, but then he shuts it again. He does know me well enough to know I’m not going to budge on this. But at the same time, I can tell he still wants it. He wants to turn that tiny terrible room into some sort of playroom or office.

“Okay,” he says. “We discuss it later.”

Or never.

TWENTY-FOUR

When I get home from work the next day, the whole house smells like glue. It’s not pleasant.

“Enzo?” I call out.

I’m pretty sure he’s home. Once again, I saw his truck parked outside the house. But maybe he’s at Suzette’s again. Maybe he’s hidden in some passageway behind the wall where I’ll never find him. After yesterday, I have no idea what to expect.

“Am here!” he miraculously calls back.

I follow the sound of his voice around the side of the stairwell. And there he is, painting glue on the wall below the stairwell. There’s a tarp beneath his boots as well as a roll of what looks like wallpaper on the floor.

“I called the Realtor,” he tells me. “I asked her where the old owners bought the wallpaper, and I got another roll.”

“Why?”

He lowers the paintbrush as he turns to look at me. “You said you want the room sealed up. So that is what I will do.”

I am astonished. I thought for sure we were going to have to have five or six more arguments about this room before he agreed to seal it up. And somehow, here he is, doing it of his own free will. I haven’t had to nag him once.

“I’m sorry I argued with you yesterday,” he says softly. “I understand how you feel. And the truth is…” He looks at the crack in the wall that is the only remaining sign of the fact that there is a door concealed within; even the hinge is on the inside. “It makes me nervous too.”

At his words, a shiver goes through me. That room is so tiny and stifling. I can’t imagine what it would be like to be trapped inside there. Well, actually, I can imagine it. That’s the problem.

He reaches for my hand with the one that isn’t holding the glue. “Is better now?”

I take his hand and start to say yes, but then a terrible fear grips me. We haven’t looked inside this room since yesterday. What if one of the children went inside again? What if we sealed the room up with them trapped in there? It is, after all, soundproof.

“Can you open the door?” I ask him.

He frowns. “But… is covered with glue.”

He makes a good point. There is glue completely coating the wall, which would make it exceptionally hard to open. Yet I can’t stop thinking about the idea that somebody could be trapped in there. And next time I hear the scraping, it will be that person trying to escape.

“Millie?”

I swallow a lump in my throat. “I just… I’m worried that…”

“The kids are upstairs,” he says gently. “I asked them if they wanted to help before I got started.” He adds, “They did not.”

Okay, I’m being ridiculous. There’s no reason to wrench open this door and make a huge mess just because I’m paranoid. “I can help you.”

He beams at me. “I would love your help.”

So we get to work spreading the pieces of wallpaper over the hidden door. I can’t quite rest easy until the door is completely covered. And even then, I can’t shake the feeling that this hidden room will come back to haunt me.

TWENTY-FIVE

I’m in my office at work when I get the call from the kids’ school.