“Claire, I can explain.”
Those are his first words? Not I’m sorry? All he wants to do is justify his misguided choice. “I’m not sure I want you to explain anything. I just came to give this back to you.”
For my entire childhood, I lived in fear. Never knowing what might happen next, I was always darting looks over my shoulder. I am grateful Lizzie has not been subjected to growing up in that type of caustic atmosphere. Still, I can’t shake those traumatic memories from my mind when situations like this arise. I took for granted that I knew what she was doing and where she was going. It was only supposed to involve a walk down the sidewalk and back. What if she found herself in danger? What if something went wrong? How could I allow myself to become so sidetracked with my personal emotions and issues? I failed to look after the teenager left in my care.
I thrust the sketchbook at Jack, as if touching it for any longer will send a crippling electric shock through me. A peculiar energy and sense of courage emerge after releasing my grip on it. My decision to let go has freed me from his beguiling influence.
“How could you do this?” The words spew from my mouth with conviction. While that final word, this, pertains to this particular incident, it runs much deeper, and he knows it. “I thought . . .”
No, don’t go there. “I’m responsible for Lizzie. I’m the adult, not her.” How could I allow the innocent charm of small-town life to cloud my judgment? “How did you think this was okay, hiding this from me? Why did you feel the need to?” He’s staring directly at me, eyes connected with mine, trying his best to see what’s inside me. “Are you going to say something? Anything?”
“I . . .” Another shuffle behind us comes at the most inopportune time. It’s probably a fisherman looking to snag a catfish for dinner tonight. The footsteps stop moving, and all I hear is the stream gurgling past. If only I could toss all these confusing emotions into the water and allow the current to carry them far away.
Jack looks over my shoulder, to the place where the stranger waits to pass. “Hi, Hank.”
Hank? I turn around to find an equally guilty look on his face, along with a bag of peaches in his hand. “What are you doing here?” If my feelings are a jumbled mess, my understanding of what’s happening is even more confusing.
“I guess Lizzie’s not coming today.” I can’t tell whether it’s a statement or question.
“That would be a safe assumption.”
“It was Lydia’s idea. Sort of.” Please, someone give me the strength to understand these cryptic words. I cross my arms and stand waiting. My posture and silence let both of them know I want an explanation. Now.
“Lydia kept looking for new things that Lizzie might want to paint. But I could tell her heart was being pulled elsewhere.” He shifts the bag of peaches to his other hand. “When Jack arrived in my shop at the same time Lizzie was there, we . . . I had an idea. We meant to include you, but . . . well . . . we didn’t.”
So Hank is as much to blame as Jack? This situation has moved from bad to worse. Someone I thought was a trustworthy friend has gone behind my back. For something I probably would have allowed after a proper discussion.
“Claire, I’m sorry.” At least Hank has the courage to say those words.
I glare at Jack, wondering if he’ll follow suit. When he doesn’t, I redirect my focus to Hank. “I trusted you.” I know there’s hurt in my voice, vulnerability exposed again. I can’t stop it this time. Flashing another quick glance at Jack, I notice genuine regret in his eyes. “And I wanted to trust you.”
I won’t remain here any longer. I climb the uphill path toward a town that now feels less like home.
“Claire, wait.” I pause for a short second, contemplating the urgency in Jack’s words. With determination, I march forward, never turning around. I’m done waiting for things to go right for me.
14
I understand Lizzie is not innocent in this lapse of judgment. But she’s still a young girl with a malleable mind. How do I broach this conversation with her—especially after the talk we had about her mom and mine?
I’m not her mother, nor her parental guardian. But if she looks up to me as Russell says, I need to say and do something. And I sure don’t want to mess it up like everything else in my life.
I walk more slowly back home. That final word creates a bitter taste in my mouth. Home. I chew on it and contemplate spitting it out, but I can’t. Not yet. Does the universe ever stop making things so difficult?
I FIND HER WHERE I knew she’d be, sitting in the same rocking chair. We’re more alike than we are different, even if separated by twenty-five years. She doesn’t see me, and it’s surprising that she’s touching up a painting of the garden. When has she been working on that?
The sight of her work creates a momentary glimpse at contentedness. I try to exhale some of my negativity. When Lizzie notices I’m watching her, she hurriedly closes her sketchbook. Why is everyone so intent on hiding things from me?
I run my palm over the side railing and lean against it. The reflection of my garden in the kitchen window catches my eye. It supplies me with some gentle motivation. “We should talk.”
“I know.” The way she speaks, it reminds me how mature she is for her age.
“What happened?” It’s an open-ended question, a chance for Lizzie to approach it from whatever angle works best for her. She’s silent, staring off into the distance. I realize she can’t possibly read the flurry of thoughts racing through my mind, so I try something different. “Why didn’t you tell me?”
“I didn’t know how.” She grips her brush tighter, as if unwilling to let go of some intangible thing. “Whenever I asked my dad to go somewhere new, he promised we’d find the time. But we never did. He was always too busy with work. So I stopped asking.”
A deep inhalation is followed by a sigh filled with frustration. I sense her painful disappointment. “When someone else offered to do that for me? And have the chance to get tips from Jack? He’s so talented . . . I couldn’t say no.” Lizzie glances over at me, and I see the guilt in her eyes. “Well, I didn’t say no. I’m sorry. It was wrong.”
I appreciate her honesty, but she hasn’t answered the burning question inside. “But why didn’t you just ask me? I would’ve said it was okay.” I fib a little. Knowing what I do now, I’m not sure I would have been comfortable allowing it.
“I noticed something between you and Jack that day.” That day. Yes, there was something, and I guess it was plain for everyone to see. “I didn’t want to make you any more uncomfortable.” What did she observe happening between Jack and me? While I felt a strong connection, did she sense nervous tension? “That, and I was afraid you’d say no.”
Lizzie’s more grown up than I was at her age, providing the complete truth. Even when she could hide behind someone else’s bad choices.
“It’s not Jack’s fault.” Her words attempt to defend his actions. I need to put a stop to that mistruth.
“Actually, he is as much to blame as anyone. Hank too.”
“They told me to share it with you, but I never did.” That bitter taste in my mouth becomes a little less sour. Still, they should have been up front with me.
“I realize we don’t spend a lot of time together, but you can talk to me. You know that, right?”
She nods her head in agreement, looking down at her lap. “I just wanted to be strong and independent.” She pauses for a second, glances at me, then stares out toward the garden. “Like you.”
If only she could understand the truth. Life is hard and confusing. Is this what it means to be strong? To do what you know in your heart is true, even when it goes against what everyone else believes is the right thing to do?
It would be hypocritical to tell Lizzie otherwise. I would have made the exact same choice. It’s also what Hank, and even Jack, has done. Nurturing a young artist who needs to prove something to herself. Even when it goes against what I believe. Or might believe.
